Skip to content

Beekeeping

A royal sighting, several births, and neon-bright pollen

Today was an epic day at the hive. The ladies are finally starting to really draw out comb on the plastic foundation, though strangely they seem uninterested in the one foundationless frame I slipped between two drawn out frames full of nectar. I suspect the progress is largely due to Jim telling me I was mistaken in leaving the mite board in all summer, and my finally taking it out – I thought I was being a conscientious beekeeper by constantly keeping an eye on it, but in fact I was just making it harder for the ladies to cool off the hive in the endless heat wave we’ve had here this summer. Oops!

Jim also told me a fascinating fact about beehive ventilation: when it’s hot, apparently the ladies line up on the floor of the hive in rows. If you pull the entire hive up from the base, all supers at once, you can catch them at it and see that some rows fan to the front, some fan to the back. And some hives are right-handed in how they direct the air flow, and some are left-handed. The best part is that hives are consistently right-handed or left-handed from season to season. I hypothesize that this is somehow genetic and determined by the queen, and would be fascinated to test to see if it changes when hives are re-queened.

We have a growing population of beekeepers in NYC. What do you say, folks? Can I grab a few tall, strong friends and do an annual or biannual survey of your hives to see which way they fan, and if it changes when you requeen? It’s for science!

Back to my hive:

Brilliant day for the bees. As you can see above, over the past week they must’ve found a source of some intensely orange, neon-bright pollen that they’re storing in frames near the edge of the second super that they never really bothered to fully draw out before. I have to wonder what kind of plant this stuff is coming from, since it looks totally alien. One lady landed on my watch and shook some yellower pollen onto it while trying to check the time, so I surmise that they have multiple sources.

We’ve become so calm with them, calm as they are with us – forget jackets and closed toe shoes, pants tucked careful into socks. Selena and I do hive inspections in shorts or skirts, sandals, tank tops. We unzipped our veils from the jackets and wear them loosely over our heads. I still haven’t been stung by my hive. They land on my arms and legs, crawl mischievously along the sole of my foot when I slowly take a step, but they don’t attack. Selena lifts her skirts to brush bees off her legs before we go inside, but no one seems to mind. We have a relaxed understanding, and a comfort level I’d never expected to achieve.

The bad news is that I found a single bee wandering on the ground with one wing bent in what might’ve been K wing, or might’ve just been the raggedness that comes with age. Since I found a single bee that looked similar earlier in the summer (and none since), I gathered this one into a tupper to be on the safe side. She’s interred in my freezer at the moment, and at some point this week I’m going to dissect her and examine her trachea for mites with my goddaughter’s microscope. Worst comes to worst, we’ll treat for mites. Even if there are some, it doesn’t seem to be a huge systemic problem, given the tons of healthy bees I see in the hive nowadays, and only two iffy ones all summer.

And back to the good news – the queen lives! We saw Her Majesty (Esther? Vashti? Shekhina?) wandering around a frame in the second super, looking big and healthy as can be. I’ve been worried all summer that I wouldn’t be able to find her quickly even if she was on a frame I picked up, but in fact she jumped right out at me. I’ve noticed that drones also stand out for me nowadays – it turns out that if you spend enough time staring at bees, even slight variations in size (drones) or more-than-slight ones (the queen) trigger the eyes immediately as something strange and worth noticing. Like when you’re at a party and you notice THAT PERSON across the room, no matter the crowd of faces and limbs around them. Your eyes adjust to the default, and the unusual jumps out.

We also saw a few baby bees chewing their way out of their cells into this glorious world of pollen and sunlight for the very first time, today. Tiny fuzzy bee heads peeking imperfectly from ragged holes in the capped comb, struggling towards the light. The other bees on the frame approach, seeming to want to help, though I don’t know if they actually do. It’s a miracle. Welcome to the world, ladies! It’s not so bad – warm and bright, with a cool breeze up on the rooftop today, and you can hang out on the front of the hive drinking mint juleps and sweet tea with your sisters as dusk approaches.

The new queen is doing well

On June 26th, I carried my new queen to my hive in a paper bag on the Q train, as pictured above. My then-second super was pretty much fully drawn out and getting filled up with what might be condensed sugar syrup and might be nectar (proto-honey!). I ultimately added a new second super in the middle, and put the queen excluder between the second and third, so that hopefully that drawn out one can eventually become comb honey. We’ll see. I tasted a little bit of it, and it definitely tasted like honey, not sugar syrup.

To introduce the new queen, I took a frame out of the first super and hung her cage in its place (cork removed and candy plug pierced carefully with a nail). This is how we hang queen cages in NYC: Attach a metrocard to the top of the cake with a thumbtack and suspend the cage between two frames by laying the metrocard on top of the frames.

When I went back three days later, on June 29th, the new queen had already been released from her cage.

Also, sort of amazing – the bees built this burr comb (comb in an undesirable location) in the empty space around the queen cage sometime between that Saturday afternoon and the next Tuesday morning:

One piece was hanging off the bottom of the queen cage, and the other was hanging off the frame above the empty space next to the queen cage. It’s empty and dry and gorgeous and alien. It smells amazing. I can’t decide what to do with it, but oh, I love it so.

On July 2nd, I peeked in again, just to make sure the new queen was laying. I saw very little comb production in the new second super, but to my absolute delight, I saw tiny eggs in several of the frames down in the first super. Success! She was accepted and has a good laying pattern! I fed them a bunch more sugar syrup again to help stimulate wax production, and left them to it.

On July 11th, my mother bravely donned a veil and joined me with the bees. I saw capped brood and uncapped larva in the first super. The second super was maybe 60% drawn out, and I saw a lot of eggs in there, beautifully arranged. The third super is still slowly on its way to becoming honey. It started to rain during my inspection, so I quickly closed things up – but ack, problem, since given their rate of wax production when they really get going, another week could be too late for adding another super.

Luckily the rain stopped quickly, so I dragged another super up from the basement and my father helped me insert it above the second super and below the queen excluder and third (now fourth) super. It’s full of wax-coated plastic foundation, which is a first for my hive. I guess we’ll see how that goes when I check in again tomorrow.

We actually didn’t bother to put on veils or light up the smoker before putting in the new super after heading back up to the roof. Everything just seemed so calm, and with two people it was a quick, simple maneuver. Our courage was justified and neither of us got stung. Man, I am going to be so surprised when I finally get my first sting from this hive!

Okay, ladies. Carry on. New bees should start hatching any day now, so maybe you’ll finish up some honey for us soon?

I seem to be missing my queen

When I checked in on my hive two weeks ago, everything looked great. They’d just barely started to draw out the comb in the second super, and I saw a healthy brood pattern downstairs. They seemed to have plenty of space to expand, so I fed them more sugar syrup and went out of town for a short trip.

When I checked in yesterday, there was no brood. No larva. Nothing. The top super was almost fully drawn out, and full of nectar (or perhaps sugar syrup from the feeder) being condensed. I couldn’t find my queen anywhere, nor any signs of her existence.

Maybe a swarm, I thought? But I doubt it. I didn’t see any swarm cells – just a single open queen cell high up on one frame, and even there I couldn’t tell if anyone was inside. I’ve never heard of a swarm leaving just one maybe queen cell behind, though maybe it does happen. Even so, there were plenty of bees around! It didn’t look like a shortage at all.

So, maybe she was accidentally crushed during an earlier inspection? I don’t know. Given the total lack of brood, I suspect she was dead or gone before I looked in two weeks ago, unfortunately. I just didn’t catch it until now, because of my ill-timed vacation.

As Roger and Jim have both told me, beekeeping is always a crapshoot, and that’s what makes it so humbling.

Luckily, someone in our local group has a spare queen that she’s giving me to install today. I’ll order a new queen for her as a replacement, so I still have the expense, but at least I’m getting a queen in there as quickly as humanly possible.

And on the plus side, I tasted some of the capped honey in the second super, and it’s definitely honey. There may be some condensed syrup in there, but they’ve surely been gathering nectar, too! Amazing. I cut off a bit of it into a small container and have been wandering around with it in my bag for the past day, occasionally sticking my finger in and licking it with wonderment.

Growing pains

As you can see, the ladies now have a duplex of their very own. When I saw that they’d fully drawn out about 6 of the 10 frames in the bottom super last week, I figured I’d have to install a second super on my next visit. A week later, they’d finished drawing out 9 of the 10 frames. Whew, close call!

I swapped the one undrawn frame in the bottom super with a drawn frame next to it, so the bees would be more likely to draw it out instead of just moving upwards. Now they have tons of space into which they can expand their brood nest. Get to it, ladies! The sooner you build up the colony, the sooner I can start pilfering your hard-earned honey!

My other task this past weekend was dealing with an unfortunate mold infestation that started in the sugar syrup in my hive top feeder and on the inside of the outer cover over the feeder. I washed off the cover and the feeder with bleach and water, then rinsed them and put them back. All the syrup I’d fed the bees the week before was gone, so I poured in another gallon. This time, however, I mixed a teaspoon of bleach in with my 1:1 sugar syrup to keep the mold down.

I’m told by one of my local mentors that bees can handle even two teaspoons of bleach per gallon of syrup, but since I wasn’t being meticulous about scrubbing everything out after the cleansing, I decided to play it safe. Hopefully this’ll do the trick, and I will never have to bleach the bees again. The great and terrible Clorox genocide was a nightmare, as bees kept flying into my bleachy cleaning water and dying in there faster than I could get them out. I lost a dozen or two, easy. Ladies, ladies, I can only protect you from yourselves up to a point!

There’s a lot of beautiful capped brood in my hive, in a perfect brood pattern curving up from the bottom center of the frames. My first new bees should start emerging in the next week or so. Since my queen came from a different hive than the rest of bees, and I have no idea what sort of drones she may have sown her wild oats with, the new bees could be quite different from the ones I started out with.

The bees I have right now are astonishingly gentle. Even with a laying queen and improving morale, even with my clumsiness and unfortunate beeslaughter by bleaching, they haven’t stung me once. They’re just pretty chill, is all. But as they die out and are replaced by bees from different genetic stock, will hive remain as calm? I just don’t know. My queen was also bred for gentleness, but only time will tell.

I’m fascinated by the idea that my hive’s personality could shift drastically over the next few weeks, as the new queen’s offspring take over. Who knows who it might become?

My brother came up to visit the ladies with me this time. Everyone looks great in a beekeeping veil!

The Queen is Free

Sometime between Thursday and today, the bees released the queen from her cage on their own, eating through the candy plug entirely. They even built some burr comb (wax comb that is out of place) on the side of the cage, and filled it up with condensed sugar syrup! I took the empty queen cage home with me as a souvenir.

Yes, I did stick my tongue into the burr comb to taste the sugar syrup. Wouldn’t you?

The bees have done a great job of building up lots of new comb over the past week. I’m seriously impressed. In a week or two, I’m going to go back in to check for evidence that the queen is laying eggs properly, but for now, this is the good news I’d hoped to see.

(Both photos in this post are better when seen large! Click on each to get to the large version.)

First Hive Inspection

That’s a close-up of the queen cage with a few bees hanging out all over it. (Bigger version.) This was taken after we shook off most of the bees that were clinging to it when we first pulled it out.

Beekeeping is amazing. Thrilling, relaxing, and meditative, all at once. Immensely satisfying. I end up covered with the smell of smoke and sugar syrup together. It’s like firespinning and working with liquid nitrogen all rolled up into one. Focus, sublime focus, and a dangerous pleasure that only works if you can enter a state of smooth calm when working with it.

This is my setup:

The box on the ground in front of the hive was the package. We’ve since fully cleared it of live bees and thrown it away. It looks like most of the bees that remained there after we left last time did manage to find their way into the hive without freezing to death. Phew!

We opened up the hive and pulled out a few frames, hanging them on this useful doohicky with two arms that hooks onto the edge of the hive when it’s open. The bees didn’t seem to mind at all. This let us pull out the queen cage to examine it.

The queen and her attendants were still trapped inside the cage by the sugar plug, which was only partially eaten away. She looked fine. The other bees were totally covering the cage, but they didn’t seem hostile, just interested – I don’t think she’s in much danger of being balled. (When a colony rejects a foreign queen, they kill her by surrounding her as a group and overheating her to death.)

I poked a wider hole all the way through the sugar plug with a screw – not wide enough for the queen to get out, but surely enough to really help inspire them to finish the job. If they haven’t released her when I check back in a few more days, I’m probably just going to do it manually. They’ll have had a week to get used to her scent, and they don’t seem to be acting aggressively towards her, so it should be fine.

Yep, that was Selena being insanely badass and beekeeping in a skirt. The rest of us wear pants, and pull our socks up over our pants to keep bees from climbing up inside. But oh, no, not her. She has to be all tough. It’s like she’s all, I’ve been to the waaaaaaaaaaar, this is nothing.

Those little glints of golden light in the air in front of her? Yeah, those are bees.

That’s it for now. The bees have started building some comb, and they seem to be doing well. Anderson has been emailing me to reassure me that they haven’t suddenly disappeared. I’ll try to get some better photos of their progress next time! They are gorgeous.

Installing the bees

This is what a package of 3 lbs of bees looks like:

We brought everything up to the roof of the shul with the assistance of Anderson, who lives there and takes care of the property. He kindly agreed to take some photos of us after we got into our jackets and veils, and offered to keep the poultry waterer filled for the bees.

So there we were up on the roof, we three ladies of beekeeping.

We all wore jackets/veils, but we went barehanded. No gloves for us! The theory is that going gloveless gives you greater dexterity, which means you’re less likely to accidentally squish bees, which means they’re less likely to want to sting you in the first place.

Alyson and I had BEEKEEPER HUGS! up there in the Brooklyn sky.

Next, you can see the basic set-up. We had a single medium super hive ready, up on a pair of cinderblocks. The white and red thing in the upper left of the next photo is the poultry waterer, so they don’t bother neighbors when they get thirsty. To the right, the brown thing is the hive-top feeder for sugar syrup before they can gather their own nectar, and in front of that is a cardboard nuc box, then holding the package of bees.

As we set it up, we used the spritz bottle seen below to spray sugar syrup on all the frames that went inside the hive, so that when we dumped the bees in they’d be happy and inclined to stay put. In the process, we spilled sugar syrup all over our hands. Ack! We rinsed it off with the hose, but still.

We had a really hard time keeping the smoker lit. I’ve used a bee smoker before, but never lit one on my own, and it takes some getting used to. I got the hang of it by the second time I visited the hive, at least.

Alyson took over the photography when Anderson left us to our business.

Here, you can see me standing next to the package, about to open it up. I got white hightop sneakers to keep at the shul, and I pulled my socks up over my jeans so bees couldn’t climb up into my pants. The red strap under the hive is a ratchet strap to hold the hive together in the wind.

Photography paused during the actual hive installation, unfortunately.

We set up the hive with only 8 of the 10 frames in it. We sprayed the sides of the bee package (lightly and gently!) with sugar syrup to keep everyone happy, then smoked it a bit as well to cut their lines of communication. The smoking was probably unnecessary, but I made a point of going very gently with cool smoke, at least. More importantly, I smoked the munchkin’s knee where she’d been stung earlier, in case there was any alarm pheromone left there.

To get the bees out, we used pliers to pull off the side and bottom bits of wood from one of the sides, then held the mesh up and literally shook the bees into the space left by the missing 2 frames. It took some gentle shaking and whacking, but ultimately most of them fell in. And then there were bees in the sky and bees on the ground, bees licking spilled sugar syrup off the rooftop and bees licking spilled sugar syrup off our hands.

Alyson got a bit scared at a certain point, and we told her to just walk away and go inside if she had to. She did back away for a bit, but then she calmed down more again. I am inspired by her courage.

We pulled the can of sugar syrup out of the package box so we could get at the queen. We held her tiny cage in our bare hands and shook the bees off of it. (Literally. Thwip, bees flying through the air!) I showed the queen and her long queenly butt to the fascinated child, and then to Selena. Her cage did not come with a nail attached by a string, alas, so I used a staple from the wood we’d ripped off the box to pry the cork out of her cage, leaving only a piece of soft candy blocking her exit.

I slipped the queen cage into the hive, held by pressure between two frames, and carefully added in the last 2 frames.

We put the feeder on top, and filled it up with sugar syrup. Matchsticks in the feeder and the waterer so the bees won’t drown. Alyson helped me put the top of the hive in place over that.

I fit an entrance reducer into the hive entrance to help encourage the bees to hang out and nothing else to go in while the colony is still weak, and closed it up with the ratchet strap. Doused the smoker, cleaned everything up.

There were still a bunch of bees hanging out in the package, so I just set it near the entrance of the hive. This is normal, I’m told, and they found their way in eventually. Luckily, the chilly night air didn’t even kill most of them first.

At some point Selena’s phone rang, and she picked up and said: “Can I call you back later? Right now I’m covered in bees!”

We took a few more iphone photos at the end, before brushing the bees off. They’re not the most flattering photos ever, but oh so worth it anyway.

Her:

Me:

Then we all brushed bees off of each other with the bee brush, and went inside to take off our jackets and put away the rest of the equipment.

I’m going to order some extra hive tools, because we really kept passing mine back and forth. And we might experiment with different veils when we order a few more for guests.

Ultimately, I wasn’t stung at all, and I really calmed down about the amazing sensation of bees gently meandering along my bare skin. Selena was stung three times – once on her hand, while shaking the package, and twice through her thin sweatpants, when she crouched and squished the bees that had landed there. She didn’t seem to mind at all.

When we got back down to the basement, we found that one stray had followed us down. Selena cupped her hands around it and carried it out to the car so she could slip it into the little bug jar with the magnifying glass lid I’d bought for Alyson the day before. Oh man, someday Alyson will appreciate just how badass a mom she’s got.

We were giddy with triumph. This was one of the most extraordinary experiences of my life, in a way that I can’t do justice to here. We installed those bees so damn hard. We installed the hell outta them! There were ten thousand and THREE victorious ladies up there on that rooftop!

I initially wanted a nuc, because it’d mean a greater chance of actually getting honey this year, but now I’m really glad that I got a package. What fun to really ride this ride on our own from the very start!

Acquiring 3 lbs of bees, or, how bees are like liquid nitrogen

Me: “I’m a BEEKEEPER!”

Dave: “Well, I’m a beekeeperkeeper.”

Me: “…”

Him: “You can be a beekeeperkeeperkeeper if you want.”

• • •

I ordered my bees through the Gotham City Honey Co-op, which had them ready for pick-up on May 9th. With Alyson (age 7) and Selena in tow, I went to the bee pick-up location, rewatched this video on how to install a package of bees, got a bunch of advice from the folks organizing the order, and picked out our package.

Alyson was super excited. At one point, she giggled and said she felt like she already had bees inside her pants. We laughed, and asked her what the anticipation felt like. “Like tickling!”

A few moments later, she cried out and pulled up her pants. We saw something sticking out of a little swelling near her knee, which I immediately scraped off. She was obviously in pain. A splinter? Could it be a stinger? Hard to tell… but oh, yes, the area was swelling and reddening a bit, and it sure looked like a stinger. The organizer asked if Alyson had maybe kneeled on the floor and somehow gotten it stuck in her pants that way, and she had, so maybe.

Alyson was a bit teary, but not much. She was really chill about the whole thing. She got up, looked at the stinger, and talked about it with great interest. No problem.

A few moments later, it occurred to me that perhaps we should shake out her pants in case anything else was stuck in there. And what did we find? Oh, the dying bee inside her pants that had stung her!

MORAL: When a kid laughs and says it feels like there are already bees in her pants, there ARE already bees in her pants!

Apparently there had been a few strays, no one was really sure how, but so it goes. Selena took Alyson to take the pants!bee safely back to the tarp where the last few packages were waiting. As I asked the organizer all my remaining practical questions, they sat near the tarp and played with the strays.

I was very impressed – they just calmly hung out and encouraged bees to walk all over their hands. I told them they could go to the pharmacy and get some Benadryl without waiting for me if need be, but Alyson didn’t feel like she really needed any, and was having plenty of fun.

Here she is, cheerfully showing off the place where she was stung:

So we loaded up in the car, the bees sitting in their cage in an open-topped box between me and the munchkin in the back seat. I fretted over the driving: “Please don’t get into an accident while we have 10,000 bees in the car! It would be the worst fender bender EVER!”

Really, it reminded me of the time Dave and I got some liquid nitrogen to make ice cream with up in Boston, back in 2005 or so. We carried it back to his apartment in a $3 styrofoam cooler we’d bought at the supermarket, sploshing around between us in the back seat of a cab. It was terrifying. Driving around with 10,000 bees humming in a box between me and Alyson felt pretty similar.

(In the midst of making the ice cream, we experimented with safely sticking our hands into the liquid nitrogen with help from the Leidenfrost effect. If you go in slow and smooth and calm, an insulating pocket of vapor forms around your hand. If you move too sharply, you risk breaking out of that air pocket and burning your hand with the cold. Similarly, if you move calmly and carefully when opening up your hive, the bees won’t mind you. If you’re nervous and hasty, you’re more likely to squish and upset them, and get stung.)

Anyways, we finally arrived safely at the shul, where a couple of weeks earlier the Talmud Torah kids had helped us build the supers for the hive.

Everything was set and ready for us. After all, we already spent a day weeks ago building all fifty of the frames I’d ordered.

Nothing left to do then but get everything up to the roof and install the bees into the hive.

A quick recap on NYC beekeeping and the law

Before getting to the stories and photos, I just want to sum up what I’ve already posted on my law blog:

In 2005, I got it into my head that I wanted to take up beekeeping, which was illegal in NYC at the time. I reached out to Roger Repohl, who very kindly invited me to come up and help him out with the hives he keeps in the backyard of his church.

I couldn’t quite bring myself to keep bees illicitly, so I set about trying to change the law.

I can’t help but feel giddily proud of this. Just Food ran the campaign since 2008, but it was winter 2005-6 back when I first ran into then City Council Member David Yassky and asked him to work on legalizing beekeeping. He laughed at first, but when I explained the issue in term of urban agriculture and sustainable food and environmental issues, he took it seriously and started doing his own research. With the combined efforts of a huge group activists, he ultimately introduced legislation to fix that glitch in the health code, which led to the amendment of NYC Health Code Article 161.

What a wonderful taste of successful activism!

Since then, I’ve had a wonderful time getting to know the folks over at the Gotham City Honey Co-op and the NYC Beekeeping Meetup Group. They have free classes, discounted group equipment orders, and a lot of support.

According to the newly amended NYC Health Code Article 161, beekeepers in the city now have to file a notice with the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene with their contact information and the location of the hive. Via the NYC Beekeepers Association, here is the form you need to file in order to keep bees legally in NYC.

As for me, I’m now the resident beekeeper up on the roof at East Midwood Jewish Center.